|
|
Post by Susie Smith "Mrs. Muffintop" on Aug 20, 2009 14:32:19 GMT -5
   
Israel||Donnie||7th Place
Madagascar||Andrea||11th Place
All Stars||Donnie||3rd Place
Sri Lanka||Willie||3rd Place
Qatar||Monique||7th Place
Susie i do think you played a better game with me. I made alot of strategic moves that were risky in this game. I played as if i was shy, i had a alliance with everyone on my original tribe and i made 3 final 2 deals. Again being honest i though strategically thos whole game. My plan in final 4 was to vote you out Susie. I had a final 2 deal with both Merlin and Keith and i didnt have one with you so by voting you out i would of been guranteed a spot in finals for sure. I also knew that if i had faced you in finals i dont think my chances of winning would be that good. You were probably one of the obvious power players this season.Ugh This really sucks. I have enver respected your gameplay. You always do nothing and make it seem like you did alot more than you actually did. I should have seen this. I don't like Rewarding your gameplay as its Floating at its best, when hard working players like me and Kristy could have won  .
So I still have a hard choice, Reward the better Floater or Reward the Floater who had a couple good game moves, but backstabbed me... |
|
|
|
Post by ~KrIsTy MoRgAn~ on Aug 21, 2009 0:54:58 GMT -5
I just want to wish you both good luck....I am still undecided on how i'm voting, since I am friends with both of you and think you both played similar games!
|
|
|
|
Post by Keith Greene on Aug 21, 2009 2:54:28 GMT -5
Hey guys,
I know I've asked question before. But I'm confused it seems like some people are saying Kristy was the strongest player, others say Susie and some say me ;D.
So I would like to get your guys opinions before Kristy's, Susie's and My minds are not made up.
Please rank the jury from 1-7. 1 being the strongest player and 7 being the weakest.
|
|
|
|
Post by Susie Smith "Mrs. Muffintop" on Aug 21, 2009 3:34:43 GMT -5
If someone says Keith played the first or second best game I will laugh, at best he played 4th.
Also, I still can't make up my mind, please compare us all to survivor players.
|
|
|
|
Post by Keith Greene on Aug 21, 2009 3:37:52 GMT -5
^^ You wanna go me homey!
|
|
|
|
Post by Susie Smith "Mrs. Muffintop" on Aug 21, 2009 4:57:09 GMT -5
Me Kristy and Poh and Maybe even Patti played better games then you, I am sorry.
|
|
|
|
Post by Keith Greene on Aug 21, 2009 6:10:16 GMT -5
Ok. That's it I'm gonna kick your ass! *Smashes Susie and instead of getting pulled away by security everyone just stands there and laughs* OWNED!
|
|
|
|
Post by Tori Hall on Aug 21, 2009 7:31:35 GMT -5
Gota go to school but ill answer them when i get back.
|
|
|
|
Post by Poh Ling Yeow on Aug 21, 2009 13:34:26 GMT -5
Hey guys I've had a great chance to peruse this entire thread and now I just feel like I have to say a few things. First of all, Tori, I really must say this: Your strategy of making an alliance wiht everyone was WAYYY to risky. And just in case people didn't know, we also had an F2 lol  I realise now that because you're only 16 you can't really possess that much know-how and that's fair enough and definitely not an insult... but yeah you were very, very lucky to get where you are at. Just be careful next time...this season you were playing against a bunch of arrogant thickheads, myself included, who weren't really on the lookout for anything and weren't on the ball. Be careful for your next game tori... And after reading everything...I'm actually going to change my vote. Oh but I have one question that I would love you guys to answer  I would like you both, to rank every juror from best to worst in terms of game play. I would then like you to, for each juror, say who they are most like from the real show and why. Now these answers could change my vote again, so this is not meaningless. Good luck with your answers...oh and just as a hint in wording your answers, laziness will get you nowhere with me, flattery will get you nowhere with me, lack of survivor knowledge will get you nowhere with me (it is not hard to do a wikipedia search) and honesty will get you EVERYWHERE with me. |
|
|
|
Post by Tori Hall on Aug 21, 2009 16:20:39 GMT -5
Hey guys, I know I've asked question before. But I'm confused it seems like some people are saying Kristy was the strongest player, others say Susie and some say me ;D. So I would like to get your guys opinions before Kristy's, Susie's and My minds are not made up. Please rank the jury from 1-7. 1 being the strongest player and 7 being the weakest. 1. Kristy- Kristy this season you were the power player and ive noticed that you are a hard core competitor in all the seasons you play in. I totally respect you for that. 2. Poh- Poh you were kinda like Kristy in a way. A lot of people were threatend by you in this game. You are a true competitor. 3. Keith- You made it all the way to final 4 being the last person from your original tribe left. 4. Susie you played on heck of a game. At first i wasnt really threatend by you but once we had got down to the final 6 you became a contender and dominated up to final 3. 5. Patti- During the game me and you were friends i i think you played a clean game. 6. Luke- Luke i only got to talk to you a lil bit in this game. 7. Cecelia- Same as Luke i only talked to you a little in the game. I think while you were in the game and once we merged and my tribe had yours outnumberd you tried your best to stay in. |
|
|
|
Post by Tori Hall on Aug 21, 2009 16:35:22 GMT -5
Hey guys I've had a great chance to peruse this entire thread and now I just feel like I have to say a few things. First of all, Tori, I really must say this: Your strategy of making an alliance wiht everyone was WAYYY to risky. And just in case people didn't know, we also had an F2 lol I realise now that because you're only 16 you can't really possess that much know-how and that's fair enough and definitely not an insult... but yeah you were very, very lucky to get where you are at. Just be careful next time...this season you were playing against a bunch of arrogant thickheads, myself included, who weren't really on the lookout for anything and weren't on the ball. Be careful for your next game tori... And after reading everything...I'm actually going to change my vote. Oh but I have one question that I would love you guys to answer I would like you both, to rank every juror from best to worst in terms of game play. I would then like you to, for each juror, say who they are most like from the real show and why. Now these answers could change my vote again, so this is not meaningless. Good luck with your answers...oh and just as a hint in wording your answers, laziness will get you nowhere with me, flattery will get you nowhere with me, lack of survivor knowledge will get you nowhere with me (it is not hard to do a wikipedia search) and honesty will get you EVERYWHERE with me. I think im going to keep the list the same as i posted for Keiths question but i will say who you all remind me of  1. Kristy You remind me of Parvati from Survivor Micronesia. You played a strong strategic game and did whatever it took to win. 2. Poh you remind me of Natalie from Survivor Micronesia. You where a nice person personally and a kickass player. 3. Keith you remind me of Earl from survivor Fiji. You played a clean game and was never rude to anyone in the progress of the game and like Earl you got far being the only one left from your first original tribe. 4. Susie you mind me of the actual Susie on the show Survivor Gabon. At first in the beginning of the game noone would think you had what it took to win but when it got down to it and we only had a few rounds left you dominated. 5. Patti you remind me of Alexis from Survivor Micronesia. You were such a sweet and nice person that played a clean game. 6. Luke you remind me of Alex from Survivor Fiji. I think even though the odds were against you at a point in the game you played your best. 7. Cecelia you remind me of Cassandra from Survivor Fiji. You were kinda quiet in the game. Idk then again maybe it cause i didnt talk to you that much. |
|
|
|
Post by Merlin on Aug 21, 2009 18:43:20 GMT -5
Keith and Poh
Since you two both asked questions that could be answered together, I will do so.
Jury Rankings
1. Kristy - Kristy was the powerhouse that had the majority of the players under her spell for the majority of the game. I'm actually very curious to know who she would have had ultimate loyalty to in this game. In any event, her downfall was that she was so openly a threat to win this whole thing. She went out cause she probably would have beaten anyone in the F5.
2. Keith - Keith was the last remaining Lang Co and worked his way all the way to the F4 and was a favorite to win. He did this and still didn't develop any enemies on the jury in the process. At least, no vocal enemies. He was the definite underdog in this game and nearly pulled it off.
3. Patti - Patti was very much in the loop in this game. Much more than I think people realized. She realized Kristy's connections very early on and was the sole player come the merge to try to do anything about it. As Poh said, there were a lot of stubborn people in this game, so Patti's game was ended because of it.
4. Poh - Poh put a lot of effort into this game and was definitely playing hard. Unfortunately, she seemed to have a bit of tunnel-vision. I knew of Poh's F4 alliance in the original PXP that involved Kristy, Tori, and Patti. I also knew of Poh's plan to oust the male characters at the merge. She put her trust in people that weren't going to reciprocate it. Maybe it never got back to her that people were double-dealing in this game (at least not until F7 when Patti tried to point it out to her), but she was playing to hard in the open with people who wanted to be the ones to control things, instead. Had she asked a different combination of people or had people's loyalties just been slightly different, she could have been the biggest threat and the one to beat. Unfortunately for her, it didn't work out in her favor this game.
5. Susie - If I was only looking from the second half of the game on, you would be much higher on this list. However, I am looking at the game as a whole. In the original PXP, you would go missing for days at a time. Me, Kristy, Poh, and Patti were there every day, giving our all in the challenges to keep the tribe strong. I actually got multiple messages about how you needed to go if we lost a challenge to keep our tribe strong. Now, I will say that once the merge came, you started investing more time in this game and come F5, you definitely made a bold move in going after Kristy. At F4, you talking to me was also a good idea. I could have beaten both you and Keith in a tie and before we talked, I would have been fine with either of you going (Tori has even said here that she was going with me from that point on, so the tie would have happened and I would have won). So, talking to me and letting me know you wanted to work with me was another good move of yours. You had a very strong second-half. Had your first half been anywhere near as good, you would be much higher on my list.
6. Celia - You actually weren't originally meant to go the round that you did. I know you talked to a few people, but don't really know what you may have done to save yourself. People were setting things up so that either Keith or Patti would go. Once I was told I was the swing vote, I feverishly went to save my close ally Patti. I let Patti know about the plan to get her out and went to Kristy about preserving our alliance and got her to go after a different person, instead. That target landed on you.
7. Luke - As I said in a previous answer, I think you were done in by a twist and didn't get the opportunity to show what you can do in this game.
Earth vs CBS Comparisons
Kristy - Burton (Pearl Islands) - You played a very strong game and were a threat in challenges. You were taken out by allies at F5 because you were such a threat.
Keith - Danni (Guatemala) - You came from the smaller tribe come the merge and all of your former tribemates were picked off, but then you found a niche and worked your way into a good position. Unfortunately for you, unlike Danni, your status as a threat to win if you made it to the end was known and it made it so that no one was willing to take that risk if they could help it.
Patti - Shii Ann (All Stars) - You knew exactly who the threat was in the game, worked to get that person voted out, but no one would listen to you. You had a good sense of the game and where things stood, but the stubbornness of others was your undoing. That, and openly going after people who had the power.
Poh - Gregg (Palau) - You were a strong player who was aligned to another strong player. The other strong player was the one who came out on top in this game, as it did with Gregg. Maybe in another game with different players, things would have ended up differently.
Susie - Neleh (Marquesas) - Not much of note was done by this player in the first half of the game, but once the merge came, it seems as if something kicked her into gear and she began playing the game hard. Had she made the end, she would have had a strong case as to why she should have won.
Celia - Morgan (Guatemala) - You seemed like a nice person and no one had anything against you. However, when TC came and two other people were targeted, they both had people on their side who really didn't want them to go home and in talks, the target shifted towards someone that no one seemed to be vehemently opposed to. It just happened to land on you.
Luke - Michelle (Fiji) - Who knows what this player would have accomplished had the merge occured when the players were expecting. Instead, we got reshuffled into new tribes for a round (just like Michelle getting placed in that group at the F10 challenge). This twist at the expected merge point ended both of their games.
|
|
|
|
Post by Keith Greene on Aug 21, 2009 20:14:31 GMT -5
Thnx for answering my questions again guys. Merlin you seem to know more about the Survivor TV show from those answers. But my guess is you've only seen 3 or 4 seasons, Tori. So that's understandable. |
|
|
|
Post by Poh Ling Yeow on Aug 22, 2009 0:33:18 GMT -5
Ahahahahaha Tori, did you really just call me and Patti "nice" and "sweet" ?!?!?!?!?!?!?! ROFLMAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  Thank you for your answers the both of you. I now know who deserves to win this game, and hopefully that person will win. |
|
|
|
Post by luke on Aug 22, 2009 16:10:54 GMT -5
To be honest I think were I was placed in this game is right. Thats b/c I didnt play this game whole hearted. I played just to play and really it didnt bother me that I got voted out I was kind of glad it was over for me. I dont think this game was to the hosts standards.
Luke
|
|
.
